Can you really starve the "bad" bacteria in your gut?

A short rant about gut health and the "wellness" movement

(Disclaimer: This is NOT medical advice, only a brief summary of current research)

Short answer: not exactly—and trying to do so might backfire.

There’s a lot of talk online about “starving bad bacteria” in the gut with strict diets, cutting out certain foods or more extreme methods that can be dangerous. But the gut microbiome isn’t just a list of “good” and “bad” microbes—it’s a complex, interconnected community. And like any community, balance matters more than extremes.

Here’s what the research is showing: diets high in fiber promote a more fermentative, anaerobic gut environment. That’s a good thing. It means more short-chain fatty acid production, better gut barrier health, and less inflammation. On the flip side, diets high in fat and sugar tend to shift the gut toward a more aerobic environment—one that encourages oxidative stress and low-grade inflammation. This shift isn’t just theoretical—our lab explored it in a 2023 study published in Nature Communications link here. My friend (and now Dr.!) Swathi showed that high-fiber diets helped protect against antibiotic-induced inflammation. She found that it was able to do this by changing the gut environment to one that protects the “good” bacteria (commensals).

So yes, what you eat absolutely influences your gut microbes. But instead of trying to “starve” out certain bugs with crazy diet changes, the better strategy is to feed the whole ecosystem well. Variety, fiber, and moderation go a lot further than restriction or “gut cleanses”.

Your gut doesn’t need a war—it needs a well-stocked pantry and a little peace.

In summary:

Thanks for reading.

I’m glad you’re here :)

Mel

---

If you liked this post and want to further support me, consider subscribing:

Or, buy me a coffee :)